Check out our Christmas Menu!
Welcome to Jimmy Pecci’s Taste of Italy!
Since 1996, Jimmy Pecci’s Taste of Italy has been serving up delicious gourmet Italian food. From satisfying meals for one to fresh, shareable entrees, our market has something for everyone. We’ve got baked goods, ready-to-go meals, specialty items, and more. Swing by and taste the flavors of Italy today!
Your Home for Authentic Italian Cuisine!
If you’re looking for fresh, homemade Italian food, visit Jimmy Pecci’s Taste of Italy! With two locations in Tinton Falls, NJ, we offer a great selection of classic dishes, gourmet specialties, and a full-service market. Whether you need a quick bite, dinner for the family, or catering, we’ve got you covered.
A Place for Everyone
Our casual, family-friendly vibe sets the tone for great food and good times. Whether you’re picking up a meal to enjoy at home, sharing with loved ones, scheduling your catering events, or grabbing something special on the go, we’re here to make every bite memorable.
Fresh, Homemade Italian Food Every Day
At Taste of Italy, we make everything fresh daily. From slow-cooked sauces to flavorful pasta, we never cut corners. Our brick oven bread comes straight from Brooklyn! Whether it’s Penne Vodka, Jimmy’s Special, or the Brooklyn, every meal is made with quality ingredients and care. Love Italian food? If not, you will. We'll always make you feel at home. BUON APPETITO!
Food That Looks as Good as It Tastes
We have a broad selection of Homemade Italian Foods and Italian Imports
A Market Full of Italian Favorites
Beyond our made-to-order meals, our market is stocked with everything you need to bring Italy home. We carry a variety of imported ingredients, specialty items, and fresh deli options. From homemade sauces to cheeses and cured meats, you’ll find something special every time you visit.
Easy Ordering for Pickup and Delivery
Life gets busy, but eating well should always be easy. That’s why we offer convenient pickup and delivery options through:
- Our App (download it for Apple and Android devices)
- Our own delivery vans
- Pickup at any of our two locations
Just place your order, and we’ll have your meal ready when you need it.
Catering for Any Occasion
Planning an event? We offer catering for any occasion. From office lunches, Birthdays, anniversaries, communions, confirmations, graduations, holidays, to weddings or any special celebration.
Our catering menu is packed with Italian classics and delicious innovations that will impress your guests. No event is too big or small—just give us a call or fill out our catering form, and we’ll handle the rest.
Visit Us at One of Our Two Locations
4060 Asbury Ave, Tinton Falls, NJ 07753
1201 Sycamore Ave, Tinton Falls, NJ 07724
⏰ Hours:
Monday–Friday: 8 AM – 7 PM
Saturday: 8 AM – 6 PM
Sunday: 8 AM – 4 PM
What our guests are saying
I have been a customer for several years. I keep coming back because not only is the premade food , sauces, & soups fresh and delicious, but the butcher's meat & cold cuts are top of the line, and the staff is friendly and accommodating. I am so impressed with The Taste of Italy that I recommended them to cater my company lunches.
JoAnne L.
I love this place! I usually make my own sandwich with a simple Mozz, roasted red pepper, basil, and arugula. Always generous with the mozz. The bread is the best!!! The owner is so nice and super down to earth. Nice atmosphere here.
Virginia Z.
I eat here at least once or twice a week, and the food is always top-notch, from their subs to prepared foods. Always fresh, and prices are reasonable. Highly recommend.
Michael M.
Featuring
Delivery
Takeout
Catering
Dine In
Join & Earn – Your Meals Just Got More Rewarding!
Sign up for our loyalty program and start earning rewards every time you dine with us. Get exclusive discounts, special offers, and early access to new menu items. The more you visit, the more you earn! It’s our way of saying thank you for choosing us.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Blt, Chicken Salad Wrap, Buffalo Chicken Wrap, Caesar Salad, Bruschetta, Sandwiches, Vegetarian Food, Cucumber Salad, Grilled Chicken, Wraps, Caprese, Chicken Salad, Salad Wraps, Antipasto Salad, Pizza, Deli Sandwiches, Meatballs, Buffalo Chicken Wraps, Salads, Ravioli, Chicken Wraps, Lasagna, Prosciutto, Caesar Wrap, Tortellini, Chicken Caesar Wrap, Arugula Salad, Pasta Salad, Tuna Salad Wrap, Pasta, Subs, and Baked Ziti
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Tinton Falls, Macedonia, Wayside, Green Grove, Cooks Mills, Cold Indian Springs, Eatontown, Ocean, West Shrewsbury, Scobeyville, Oakhurst, Phalanx, Shrewsbury, West Deal, Wanamassa, Neptune, Collingwood Park, West Long Branch, Earle, Colts Neck.
